GPT-6.2 Astra and Claude Fable 5.2 head to head
Models

GPT-6.2 Astra vs Claude Fable 5.2: The Flagship Battle

Published
Reading time
11 min read
Tag

GPT-6.2 Astra takes the Elo crown from Claude Fable 5.2. We compare benchmarks, pricing, and real-world coding performance.

OpenAI shipped GPT-6.2 Astra on November 17, 2026, and it immediately claimed the top Elo rating across major benchmarks. That title belonged to Claude Fable 5.2 for eight days. We ran both models on the same set of tasks to see what the numbers mean in practice.

Quick answer. GPT-6.2 Astra wins on aggregate Elo (1,318 vs 1,271), science, legal reasoning, and computer use. Fable 5.2 wins on extended coding (FrontierCode 2.0: 49.1%), autonomous agent loops, and cost per step in long sessions thanks to $0.25 cache reads. If you need one model for everything, Astra is the safer bet today. If you run long coding agents, Fable 5.2 pays for itself in cache savings.


What changed: GPT-6.2 Astra reclaims the crown

For a week, Fable 5.2 sat at the top of every public leaderboard. It scored 65 on the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index, first among 74 models. It posted 49.1% on FrontierCode 2.0, the highest any released model had achieved. Then GPT-6.2 Astra landed.

OpenAI reports a 6.2 percentage point gain over GPT-6 Astra on its internal science benchmark, while using 22% fewer output tokens to get there. The Elo ratings from Chatbot Arena tell the same story:

ModelElo Rating
GPT-6.2 Astra1,318
Claude Fable 5.21,271
GPT-6.2 Sol1,259
Claude Opus 5.5~1,250

A 47-point Elo gap translates to Astra winning roughly 57% of head-to-head matchups on the aggregate benchmark. That is a meaningful lead, but it is not a blowout. The gap is smaller than the 100+ point spreads we saw between model generations a year ago. These two are closer competitors than the headline ranking suggests.

Elo is an aggregate, so it hides where each model is strong. The rest of this article breaks it down axis by axis, with numbers from OpenAI’s announcement, Anthropic’s Fable 5.2 release notes, and third-party trackers including BenchmarkList and OpenRouter.

Coding benchmarks: Fable 5.2 holds the edge

Coding is where the two models diverge most. Fable 5.2 was built for extended, autonomous coding work, and the numbers show it.

BenchmarkGPT-6.2 AstraFable 5.2
FrontierCode 2.0~45% (est.)49.1%
FrontierSWE v2 (20h tasks)Not reported0.57
SWE-bench ProNot reported81.2%
SWE-bench MultilingualNot reported89.1%
CursorBench 3.2.0Not reported73.4%
DeepSWE v1.1 (Sol proxy)68.8% (Sol)~70% (Fable 5.1)

OpenAI has not published FrontierCode numbers for GPT-6.2 Astra. GPT-6 Astra scored in the mid-40s on the earlier FrontierCode version, and GPT-6.2 Sol posts 49.3% on FrontierCode 1.1 (note: different version). Until OpenAI publishes direct FrontierCode 2.0 results for Astra, Fable 5.2’s 49.1% stands as the highest public score on that benchmark.

Where Fable 5.2 really separates itself is on tasks that run for hours. FrontierSWE v2 tasks average close to 20 hours each. Fable 5.2 scores 0.57 there, ahead of Opus 5 at 0.52 and GPT-5.6 Sol at 0.32. For extended multi-file refactors and bug hunts, Fable 5.2 currently leads the field by a wide margin.

SWE-bench Pro tells a similar story. Fable 5.2’s 81.2% is roughly 10 points ahead of the next best public score. SWE-bench Multilingual at 89.1% shows the model handles non-English codebases with the same fluency.

The DeepSWE row uses Sol as a proxy for the GPT-6.2 family. Sol at max effort scores 68.8%, close to Fable 5.1’s ~70%. Astra should score higher than Sol, but we cannot confirm by how much until OpenAI publishes the numbers.

What this means for you: if your primary use case is writing and reviewing code across large repositories, Fable 5.2 is the better choice. If you need coding ability as one part of a broader task (research, planning, then implementation), Astra’s overall strength may compensate.

Reasoning and science: Astra pulls ahead

This is where GPT-6.2 Astra justifies its Elo lead. OpenAI reports it as the top model on its science benchmark, 6.2 points above GPT-6 Astra.

BenchmarkGPT-6.2 AstraFable 5.2
Elo (aggregate)1,3181,271
Humanity’s Last Exam (tools)Not reported74.2%
Remote Labor IndexNot reported41.3%
FrontierMath Tier 4Near-saturated (GPT-6)Not reported
Agents’ Last Exam56.4% (Sol)Not reported

GPT-6 Astra already showed near-saturated scores on FrontierMath Tier 4 and ARC-AGI-3. A pre-release GPT-6 Astra solved 2 of 68 open conjectures in the FrontierMath Erdős challenge, the only model to solve any. GPT-6.2 Astra improves on that baseline. For math-heavy research, theorem proving, and scientific analysis, Astra is the strongest model available today.

Fable 5.2 is no slouch. Its Humanity’s Last Exam score of 74.2% with tools is a significant jump from Fable 5.1’s 65.0%. The Remote Labor Index at 41.3% measures ability to complete real professional tasks end to end. But on pure mathematical reasoning, the gap favors Astra.

This is a category where Astra has no real competitor from Anthropic. OpenAI invested heavily in domain-specific performance for GPT-6.2.

On Harvey’s Legal Agent Benchmark, GPT-6.2 Astra completed 14.6% of assignments meeting every single requirement. That is up from 4.6% for GPT-6 Astra, a 3x improvement on a benchmark designed to be difficult (most models score under 5%).

OpenAI also released Astra for Law, a specialized variant tuned specifically for legal work. Its hallucination rate drops to 0.03 errors per assignment, half the rate of base GPT-6.2 Astra (0.06) and tied for the lowest of any model tested. For contract review, regulatory compliance, and legal research, this variant is built for the job.

Anthropic has not released a legal-specific Fable variant. Claude models perform well on general legal reasoning, but the targeted optimization and third-party validation on Harvey’s benchmark give Astra a concrete, measurable advantage in this domain.

What this means for you: if legal, compliance, or regulatory work is a core part of your pipeline, GPT-6.2 Astra (or Astra for Law) is the clear pick. This is not a marginal difference; it is a 3x improvement on the benchmark that matters most in that space.

Computer use and browsing

Both models can drive a browser, fill forms, and operate desktop applications. The scores come from different benchmarks and benchmark versions, making direct comparison imperfect.

BenchmarkGPT-6.2 AstraFable 5.2
OSWorld 2.060.5% (Sol, xhigh)—
OSWorld 2.1Not reported89.3%
Terminal-Bench 4.044.4% (Sol)55.8% (Fable 5.1)
AutomationBenchNot reported31.4% (Fable 5.1)

The OSWorld comparison is tricky. The Sol score (60.5%) is on OSWorld 2.0, while Fable 5.2’s score (89.3%) is on the newer 2.1 version. We do not know whether version 2.1 is easier, harder, or roughly equivalent. Astra should score higher than Sol on the same benchmark, but OpenAI has not published its own OSWorld result for Astra specifically.

Terminal-Bench 4.0 gives a cleaner comparison. Fable 5.1 posted 55.8% there, 11 points ahead of Sol’s 44.4%. Fable 5.2 likely improved on 5.1’s score, though we do not have confirmed numbers yet.

For agents that browse the web, fill out forms, or interact with desktop software, Fable’s lineage has held a consistent advantage across multiple benchmarks. For agents that reason through complex multi-step plans before acting (where the “thinking” matters more than the “clicking”), Astra’s reasoning edge may matter more than raw computer-use scores.

Context window and token efficiency

FeatureGPT-6.2 AstraFable 5.2
Context window272K (standard), larger available1M tokens
Max outputNot published128K tokens
Token efficiency22% fewer output tokens vs GPT-6Comparable to Fable 5.1
Cache reads~$1/M tokens$0.25/M tokens

Fable 5.2’s 1 million token context window is roughly four times larger than Astra’s standard tier. For tasks that require ingesting entire codebases, long conversation histories, or extensive documentation, that raw capacity matters. You can feed Fable 5.2 a 500K-token codebase and still have room for a detailed prompt and a long output.

GPT-6.2 Astra compensates with token efficiency. OpenAI says it uses 22% fewer output tokens than GPT-6 Astra to reach the same answers. Fewer tokens means faster responses and lower cost per task, even if the context window is smaller. In our testing, this efficiency showed up as noticeably shorter (but equally correct) responses compared to GPT-6 Astra.

For multi-agent orchestration where each agent handles a focused slice of the problem, the context window difference matters less. Each agent stays within its own context budget. For single-agent setups that need to reason over massive inputs, Fable 5.2’s million-token window is a clear advantage.

Pricing: different math for different workloads

Cost (per million tokens)GPT-6.2 AstraFable 5.2
Input~$8$10
Output~$40$50
Cache read~$1$0.25
Cache write~$10 (est.)$12.50 (5-min) / $20 (1-hr)
Batch API~50% off50% off

Pricing data sourced from OpenRouter’s GPT-6 Astra listing and Anthropic’s pricing page.

GPT-6.2 Astra is 20% cheaper per token than GPT-6 Astra, putting it at roughly $8/$40. That undercuts Fable 5.2’s $10/$50 by a visible margin on base rates. For one-shot tasks (single prompt in, single response out), Astra is straightforwardly cheaper.

But cache reads flip the math for agent workloads. Fable 5.2 charges $0.25 per million cached tokens, roughly a quarter of what Astra charges. An agent that replays a 100K-token context over 50 steps pays for 5 million cached input tokens. At $0.25 per million, that is $1.25. At $1.00 per million, the same run costs $5.00. Over 50 steps, that $3.75 difference adds up.

Here is a concrete example. A coding agent that works on a 10-file refactor over 40 steps, replaying 80K tokens of context each time:

  • Fable 5.2: 40 × 80K × $0.25/M = $0.80 in cache reads, plus output costs
  • GPT-6.2 Astra: 40 × 80K × $1.00/M = $3.20 in cache reads, plus output costs (but 22% fewer output tokens)

The output savings from Astra’s efficiency partially offset the cache cost difference, but for long-running agent loops, Fable 5.2 typically comes out ahead. Short, one-shot tasks favor Astra. Know which shape your workload takes before picking.

Using both in Atomic Agent

You do not have to pick one. Both GPT-6.2 Astra and Claude Fable 5.2 are available through OpenRouter, which means any tool that supports OpenRouter can switch between them on the fly.

Full disclosure: we build Atomic Agent, an open-source AI agent runtime. It routes tasks to whichever model fits best, and you can set different models for different effort levels. A practical setup: use GPT-6.2 Astra at high effort for research, planning, and reasoning tasks, then hand off to Fable 5.2 for the actual coding session where cache reads and long context pay off. The cost stays low because each model works only where it is strongest.

You can try this in about five minutes. Install Atomic Agent, add your OpenRouter key, and configure both models in the settings. The agent picks the right one based on the task type and effort level.

What we measured ourselves

We ran one coding task through Atomic Agent v0.6.13 on OpenRouter, provider pinned to OpenAI for Astra and to Anthropic for Fable 5.2. The task is a warehouse logging library of about 1,400 lines with 13 planted bugs and one missing feature, scored by 59 hidden tests the agent never sees. Each setup ran three times.

ModelHidden testsAvg timeAvg stepsAvg cost
GPT-6.2 Astra59/59 in all 3 runs1.4 min9$0.82
Fable 5.2, medium59/59 in all 3 runs4.2 min6$1.87
Fable 5.2, high59/59 in all 3 runs26.6 min19$7.70

All three setups solved the full test suite. Astra finished faster and cheaper than Fable 5.2 at medium effort, and at a fraction of the cost at high effort. Astra used more steps than Fable 5.2 medium (9 vs 6) but each step was shorter and cheaper thanks to lower per-token pricing.

This is one task. Both models scored 59 out of 59, so it measures cost and speed, not ceiling. For a broader comparison see the benchmark tables above.

Which to pick for what

There is no single winner here. The choice depends on what you are building.

Pick GPT-6.2 Astra when:

  • Your task is primarily reasoning, math, or science
  • You need legal analysis, compliance review, or domain-specific work
  • Short, high-stakes decisions matter more than long autonomous runs
  • You want the lowest per-token cost on straightforward API calls
  • You need the latest specialized variants (Astra for Law)

Pick Claude Fable 5.2 when:

  • You run long coding sessions across large repositories
  • Your agent replays large contexts repeatedly (cache savings dominate)
  • You need the largest context window (1M tokens)
  • Autonomous computer use, browser automation, and terminal work are core to your workflow
  • SWE-bench and FrontierCode performance matter for your evaluation criteria

Use both when:

  • Different stages of your pipeline have different strengths (reasoning vs coding)
  • You want to compare results on critical decisions before committing
  • Cost optimization matters and you can route by task type
  • You are running multi-agent orchestration where each agent can use a different model

The models are closer than the Elo gap suggests. On any specific task, either model can come out ahead. The benchmarks tell you where the odds tilt; your own testing tells you which model fits your work. We will update this article with our own benchmark results from Atomic Agent within 24 hours of publication.


FAQ

Everything you need to know about running a local-first agent.

  • What is Atomic Agent?

    Atomic Agent is an open-source, local-first AI agent runtime that runs entirely on your own machine. It uses llama.cpp to serve a local model, GBNF grammars to keep tool calls structurally valid, the Model Context Protocol (MCP) to connect external tools, and a SQLite-backed memory. It's built by AtomicBot and released under the MIT license on GitHub at github.com/AtomicBot-ai/atomic-agent.

  • Is Atomic Agent free?

    Yes. Atomic Agent is free and open source under the MIT license. The easiest way to start is the desktop app for macOS, Windows and Linux from the Download page: it downloads a local model for you, and there's no token bill because the model runs on your own hardware. If you prefer the terminal, bring your own llama-server or let the CLI manage one. Either way the metered cost stays at zero.

  • Does Atomic Agent run offline, and is my data private?

    Yes — by default the agent loop, the model, and your data all run locally on your own machine, so it works without sending your data to the cloud. Cloud providers are used only if you deliberately configure them. This makes Atomic Agent a strong fit for private, air-gapped, or compliance-sensitive workflows. For a step-by-step setup, see How to run an AI agent offline.

  • How is Atomic Agent different from Hermes?

    On the GAIA Level 1 benchmark (53 tasks, run on the same model and the same hardware for a fair head-to-head), Atomic Agent scored 69.8% versus Hermes' 58.5% — that's +11.3 percentage points more accurate, solving 37 of 53 tasks. It was also about 1.6x faster per task (roughly 217 seconds versus 351 seconds on average). Unlike cloud-first agents, Atomic Agent is local-first and open source, so you keep both the accuracy and full control of your data.

  • What models does Atomic Agent support?

    Atomic Agent works with any model your local llama-server can serve via llama.cpp, so you're free to choose the open-weight model that fits your hardware and task. GBNF grammars constrain the model's output so tool calls stay valid regardless of which model you pick. The published GAIA Level 1 benchmark was run on the same model and hardware as Hermes to keep the comparison fair.

  • What operating systems does Atomic Agent support?

    Atomic Agent runs on macOS, Windows and Linux. The easiest way to start is the desktop app from the Download page: macOS 14 or later on Apple Silicon, Windows x64 and ARM64, and Linux x64 and arm64. If you prefer the terminal, the CLI (Developer Preview, v0.8.0) installs with one command and runs on macOS (Apple Silicon), Linux x64 and arm64, and Windows x64. Intel Macs are not currently built. Source and current requirements are on GitHub at github.com/AtomicBot-ai/atomic-agent.

  • Is Atomic Agent really open source?

    Yes. Atomic Agent is released under the permissive MIT license, with open weights, open source, and open traces — software you can read and audit all the way down. The full code is on GitHub at github.com/AtomicBot-ai/atomic-agent.

  • Is Atomic Agent backed by NVIDIA?

    Atomic Agent is a member of NVIDIA Inception, NVIDIA's free program for AI startups, accepted in August 2026. To be clear about what that means: Inception takes no equity and involves no funding or investment, so nobody bought a stake in the project. Membership gives us access to NVIDIA developer resources, NIM API endpoints, and cloud credits, and it means our technology was reviewed by NVIDIA. Atomic Agent stays MIT-licensed, open source, and local-first, and it runs on whatever hardware you already own — no NVIDIA GPU required. The application was filed by AtomicBot, the team that builds Atomic Agent.

  • Can I extend Atomic Agent with my own tools?

    Yes. You can connect external tools through the Model Context Protocol (MCP), teach it repeatable workflows with skills, and even drive it remotely from Telegram. Because it's MIT-licensed and open source, you can also modify the runtime itself.


Get new posts
by email

One email when we post something new.

Share
Written by
Nadya Dudka Product, Atomic Agent
Andrew Dyuzhov SEO and growth

Run your local agent
in one click